Best supermarket own brand copycat products revealed by Good Housekeeping – and it could save you HUNDREDS of pounds

Best supermarket own brand copycat products revealed by Good Housekeeping – and it could save you HUNDREDS of pounds

OWN-BRAND supermarket products that are rated BETTER than top-selling branded items have been named by Good Housekeeping. They’re all a lot c

Little Mix’s Leigh-Anne Pinnock creates swimwear brand featuring her own designs
Nintendo Switch Lite CONFIRMED: Brand new handheld revealed in surprise announcement
Russell Brand wants to apologise and ‘make amends’ with ex Katy Perry

OWN-BRAND supermarket products that are rated BETTER than top-selling branded items have been named by Good Housekeeping.

They’re all a lot cheaper than the big brands too – and they could slash a lot off your grocery bill every year if you swap famous names for the copycats.

These are some of the biggest brands available at the supermarket – but Good Housekeeping says there are some own-brand versions that are rated even better

Good Housekeeping Institute (GHI) tested types of common household items, from hazelnut chocolate spread to washing up liquid, to compare own-label products to famous brands.

Testers found that in at least eight cases, cheaper own-brand products from supermarkets including Aldi, Lidl and Tesco are actually better than brands they copy.

Lidl’s £1.09 400g Choco Nusse spread was rated higher by the judges than best-selling Nutella, which costs £2.50 for the same size jar at Iceland.

If you made all the swaps below, you could save £196 a year.

It is well-known amongst bargain hunters that factories which make branded products also produce own-brand items for supermarkets in the same place – so you could really save by switching and not miss out on quality.

Caroline Bloor, consumer affairs director for Good Housekeeping, said: “As money is tight in January, now is the perfect time for consumers to look at their supermarket spending habits to make sure they get the best value possible.

“These seven products have been taste tested by the GHI and either scored higher than similar branded products or carry the ‘GHI Approved’ logo – so now’s the time to switch for savings and not miss out on the taste.”

Weetabix v Tesco own-brand wheat biscuit cereal

Weetabix is the best-known wheat cereal brand but Tesco’s Wheat Biscuits scored better in a blind taste test – and they are £1.20 cheaper

Weetabix is the best-known wheat cereal – but there’s an own-brand version that is rated even better than Kellogg’s much-loved product.

Tesco’s 24-pack Wheat Biscuits cost £1.30 – £1.20 more than a £2.50 24-pack of Weetabix from the same supermarket.

Good Housekeeping gave Tesco’s version a 76/100 score compared to Weetabix’s 74/100 rating when it did a blind taste test of wheat biscuit cereal products.

Even better, if you make the swap you could save £4.80 month if you buy four of them in that time – or £57 a year.

Fairy Liquid v Aldi own-brand washing up liquid

Swap Fairy Liquid for Aldi’s Magnum Original washing up liquid, which is rated highly by the GHI

Fairy Liquid is the best-known washing up liquid brand but it costs customers £1.50 for a 500ml bottle at both Tesco and Sainsbury’s.

You could save £2 a month, or £24 a year, if you swap it for Aldi’s 49p Megnum Original Washing Up Liquid instead.

The product has been approved by the Good Housekeeping Institute, which described it as having “great cleaning results, especially for cutting through grease and dried on food soils”.

Nutella v Lidl’s own brand hazelnut chocolate spread

Nutella may be better known but Lidl’s Choco Nussa was preferred by blind taste testers – and it’s £1.41 cheaper

Nutella is the best-selling hazelnut chocolate spread on the market and its brand name is recognised across much of the world.

But it costs £2.50 for a 400g jar at Iceland, and up to £2.90 at other supermarkets.

Lidl’s own-brand version, Choco Nussa, costs only £1.09 for the same size jar.

And blind taste testers at the GHI said they preferred it to the famous brand.

Swapping Nutella for Lidl’s copycat product could save you £2.82 a month if you buy two jars or £33.84 a year.

Sun-Pat v M&S’s own-brand peanut butter

Swap M&S’s own brand peanut butter for Sun-Pat and you could save £1.70 a month

Sun-Pat is the market leader for smooth peanut butter, but GHI says there’s an own-brand version that’s even better – and it’s cheaper too.

Blind taste testers recommend M&S’s Smooth Peanut Butter, which costs £1.30 for a 340g jar.

Meanwhile Sun-Pat Smooth Peanut Butter costs £3 at most supermarkets for a 400g jar, so you could save £1.70 a month or £20.40 a year if you make the swap.

Persil Bio Liquid v Lidl’s own-brand biological detergent

Persil’s Bio Liquid is much more expensive than Lidl’s copycat version – and in a blind test, it didn’t perform as well

Persil may be the biggest name in laundry detergent, but it performed worse than Lidl’s copycat own-brand version in the GHI’s blind test.

Lidl’s £2.99 40-wash Formil Biological Detergent scored 90/100 compared to Persil’s Bio Liquid, which was given a rating of 89/100.

Lidl’s version is much cheaper than Persil’s Bio Liquid too, which costs £8 for a 38-wash bottle at Tesco.

Swapping Persil for Lidl’s cut-price version will save you 14p per wash.

And if you do five washes a week, that will add up to a saving of at least £2.50 a month, or £30 a year.

Tropicana v Tesco own-brand orange juice

Tropicana is the best known orange juice brand but Tesco’s Finest orange juice has more flavour and it’s 48p cheaper

Tropicana and other branded juices may catch your eye on the shelves, but GHI says opt for a luxury version from Tesco instead, and it will still save you money.

It said Tesco’s £2 one-litre Finest Orange Juice With Bits had better “zesty flavour” than other branded juices.

A 950ml carton of Tropicana will cost you £2.48, so you’ll save 96p a month if you buy two of them in that time, or nearly £11.52 a year.

Covent Garden v Co-op’s own brand carrot and coriander soup

Covent Garden’s Carrot & Coriander soup was rated worse than Co-op’s cheaper version in a blind taste test

The GHI found that Co-op’s 600g Carrot & Coriander Soup was better than Covent Garden’s same-size branded version in its blind taste test.

Co-op’s £1.80 soup scored 82/100 compared to the 72/100 rating Covent Garden’s soup received, which normally sells for about £2.

If you buy six a month, you could save £1.20, or £14.40 a year.

Covent Garden’s soup is on offer for £1 at the moment at Sainsbury’s and Iceland though, so it could be worth sticking with the brand for now.

Mr Muscle v Aldi’s own-brand bathroom cleaner

Mr Muscle’s Bathroom Cleaner costs 75p more than Aldi’s own-brand version, which is highly rated by the Good Housekeeping Institute

Mr Muscle is a very popular cleaning brand, but GHI says that you can save money without losing quality by swapping to an own-brand version.

It rates Aldi’s 75p 750ml Power Force Bathroom Cleaner highly, and has given the product an official GHI Approved sticker.

Mr Muscle’s five-in-one Bathroom Cleaner costs £1.50 at most supermarkets, so you’ll save 75p, or £4.50 a year if you get through a bottle every other month.

If you want to stop your grocery bills from soaring, then we’ve put together some handy tips to keep costs low.

We’ve also rounded up the best deals at supermarkets this week to save you even more cash.

Last week, Tesco slashed prices in a new supermarket price war for the start of the year.


We pay for your stories! Do you have a story for The Sun Online Money team? Email us at or call 0207 78 24516. Don’t forget to join the Sun Money’s Facebook group for the latest bargains and money-saving advice.